Hello Scrivener

In my last post, I left Microsoft WordPerfect because they inserted their AI, Copilot, into my documents with no way to remove it. In my quest to find a new software for my creative writing, I landed on Scrivener. I must confess this is not my first venture with Scrivener. A few years ago, in a quest to organize the research for my creative writing projects, I purchased Scrivener. My original venture with Scrivener only lasted a few short weeks. I stopped using the program because it syncs with Dropbox. I had already moved on from Dropbox. I did try syncing with iCloud, but there were some issues. Just to be safe, I also backed up to a hard drive. Afraid I would lose data, I stopped using it and went back to Word.   

For a brief moment, I entertained the idea of giving Scrivener another try but decided to see what else was available. Like most people, the first thing I did was search the internet. Of course there was page after page of ads and blogs and YouTube videos, and so on. After clicking on a few blogs that ranked writing software, Scrivener was frequently in the top five. But so was Word, Atticus, Google Docs, Ulysses, Hemingway Editor, and a few others.

In fact, it became repetitive very quickly, so I asked friends and family what writing software they used. My son uses Ulysses because of its minimalist interference and low monthly subscription fee. A young woman in my writing group uses Google Docs because it’s free. Ulysses looked interesting but not interesting enough to pay the monthly fee. Over the years, I have used Google Docs. Other than the price (free), the only other perk is that Google Docs is good for group projects. My novel is not a collaboration. 

Since none of the other writing software programs offered anything worth the fee, and I had already purchased Scrivener, I decided to give it another try. In addition to the save issues, Scrivener has a monumental learning curve. It’s an opinion shared by every blog I read. As a writing program, compared to Word, it is a little stripped down. I would not call it minimalist, but it does not have all the tools and features of Word. However, I find that to be a good thing. It forces me to pay attention rather than rely on the software.

Now, about the learning curve—the steep learning curve is mainly based around the files and folders in the binder, which is located on the left side of the Editor. The Editor is where you actually do the writing. But this post is not a how-to for Scrivener. The software does include good tutorials and a blog. There are also plenty of blogs and YouTube videos to walk writers through the start-up process. Once a writer is up and running, they could spend years learning everything Scrivener can do. The same can be said about Word.

Edmond Rane

Goodbye Word

Today, I am writing on Apple Pages. It is something I have not done for many years. Possibly decades. My preferred writing software has always been Microsoft Wordperfect. This morning, when I opened Word to work on my novel, Word did an update, which is very normal. But today’s update—Microsoft installed its AI, Copilot, directly on my document.

As a creative writer, I took extreme offense to such an intrusion into the sanctuary of my creative workspace. Once my novel is finished, I do plan on publishing. But publishing will take place when I determine the novel is complete and has gone through the editing process—not as part of the AI feeding frenzy. My creative work is mine. Microsoft and the other Big Tech companies can stay the hell out of it.

As a writing assistant, AI is great for emails, memos, reports, and other noncreative writings. Increasing productivity in the workplace is important. I am all for it. When it comes to creative writing, the writer should determine whether or not an AI assistant is on the page during the writing process—not the software developer.

Using an AI editor to check for spelling and grammar should be a choice for the writer. Inserting AI into a document with no way to remove it is not a choice. Having the Copilot icon directly on my novel is a deal breaker. So, goodbye Microsoft Word.

Now that I have said goodbye to Word, the search for a new writing software program begins. I doubt if I will stick with Pages. It is possible. Since my search begins today, I rule nothing out—except Microsoft Word.

Edmond Rane